aap logon ko ajeeb lagega par i am saying i dont like tare zameen par i am not saying it is a bad film.it is not a bad film because it has a good story line perfect three act structure. perfect changes in every character's arc, good dialogues good music, every thing is perfect amol gupte has directed a good movie.
so where is the problem?
problem is the purpose
tagline of story is every child is special.but i think special has nothing to do with the wining.
eshan ko dyslexia hai. usko padhai mein takleef hai. uska bhai first aata hai. ghar wale uske bhai ko jyada pyaar kartey hain (kyunki hum nahi dekhtey ki woh usko kabhi dantey hain jabki masoom ishaan bechara uski maa aur uske baap ko uske chehre par khoon bhi nazar nahi aata jab woh jhagda karke aata hai kya scene hai woh ulta usko dantney mein lag jatey hain. koi maa yaa baap aisa nahi karta except aamir khan jo apne bacchon ko ek assistant director ke liye chor saktey hain.)
ishaan ki masumiyat kisi ko nahi dikhai deti hai. ek avatar ki tarah aa jatey hain nikumbh sir. aur unki back story bhi same hai. woh ishaan ko theek kar dete hain aur ishaan ek art comptetion mein chapion ban jata hai. wahi dusari aur uska bada bhai tennis match har jata hai aur baad mein woh film se bhi gayab ho jata hai.
do sawal ki un bacchon ka kya hoga jo dyslexic hain par na woh ishaan jaisey painter hain na agatha cristie jaisey writer bas dyslexic hain. unke maa baap kya karein. mere bhai se discussion hua is barey mein he said it cant be shown because it is a film not a documentry. to fir hum log mani ratnam ki anjali ko itna pasand kyun kartey hain. woh ishaan ki tarah super painter nahi thi. but we love her. yeh do alag kahaniyan nahi hain yeh ek jaisi hi kahaniyan hain.
hum apne bacchon ko tabhi god mein uthayengey jab woh first ayengey kisi comtetion mein top karengey huh .
ishaan ka bhai uska sabsey acha dost hai par tennis match harney ke baad woh gayab jaisey woh koi ectra character hai. mere aur mere bhai ke beech diffrences hain par when i achieved something i felt that he is there.
hum kisi writer ya directer sey yeh expect nahi kar sakte arey yeh to main bhool gaya yeh sab intentionally kiya jata hai kyunki isme paisa lagta hai.
aap kahtey ho every child is special uska bhai tennis match har jayega to speciality khatam ho jayegi?
woh ab ishaan ka dost nahi rahega ?
uske maa baap ussey kaisey behave karengey?
maine jo feel kiya mainey wahi likha aagey aap par hai jo aap socho.
